Caviar Stick Eyeshadow Celestial Noir dupes and alternatives Laura Mercier
4.5 (4,815)·Grey · Deep / dark
Closest shade match is the equivalent shade, scored on colour, depth, undertone and colour family only. Closest overall alternative is the most similar eyeshadow overall: shade match 55%, finish, pigmentation and format 30%, wear and performance 10%, comfort and skin suitability 5%.
Overall alternativesShade matchesRanked by the overall match: the most similar eyeshadow on shade, finish, wear and comfort and skin suitability together. Each row leads with its overall match; the shade match is beneath it.
Ranked by the overall match: the most similar eyeshadow on shade, finish, wear and comfort and skin suitability together. Each row leads with its overall match; the shade match is beneath it.
Matches: Same longevity: 24-hour wear· Both claim crease resistance· Both claim comfort
Differences: Buildable rather than opaque (pigmentation)· Liquid rather than stick (format)· Does not claim waterproof
Score details
Shade match
78
Finish, pigmentation & format
75
Wear & performance
88
Comfort & skin suitability
48
Slight colour difference · Shimmer · Buildable
Ingredients (not scored): 7% ingredient overlap
Differences: Buildable rather than opaque (pigmentation) · Liquid rather than stick (format) · Does not claim waterproof · Does not claim hydration · Sensitive rather than normal, dry, combination (skin types)
Matches: Same longevity: 24-hour wear· Both claim crease resistance· Both claim comfort
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour· Buildable rather than opaque (pigmentation)· Liquid rather than stick (format)
Score details
Shade match
67
Finish, pigmentation & format
75
Wear & performance
88
Comfort & skin suitability
48
Slight colour difference · Shimmer · Buildable
Ingredients (not scored): 7% ingredient overlap
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour · Buildable rather than opaque (pigmentation) · Liquid rather than stick (format) · Does not claim waterproof · Does not claim hydration · Sensitive rather than normal, dry, combination (skin types)
Matches: Both claim crease resistance· Both claim waterproof· Both claim comfort
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour· Deeper· Black rather than grey
Score details
Shade match
63
Finish, pigmentation & format
83
Wear & performance
68
Comfort & skin suitability
80
Slight colour difference · Glitter
Ingredients (not scored): 34% ingredient overlap
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour · Deeper · Black rather than grey · 12-hour wear rather than 24-hour wear (longevity) · Does not claim hydration
$26Ulta Beauty(product price)$8 less (24%)4.8 (590)
Matches: Both claim crease resistance· Both claim comfort
Differences: Black rather than grey· Powder rather than stick (format)· 12-hour wear rather than 24-hour wear (longevity)
Score details
Shade match
69
Finish, pigmentation & format
74
Wear & performance
56
Comfort & skin suitability
80
Slight colour difference · Glitter
Ingredients (not scored): no ingredient list for one product
Differences: Black rather than grey · Powder rather than stick (format) · 12-hour wear rather than 24-hour wear (longevity) · Does not claim waterproof · Does not claim hydration
$18Ulta Beauty(product price)$16 less (47%)3.5 (165)
Matches: Both claim crease resistance· Both claim waterproof
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour· Long-wearing rather than 24-hour wear (longevity)· Does not claim comfort
Score details
Shade match
61
Finish, pigmentation & format
83
Wear & performance
85
Comfort & skin suitability
40
Visibly different colour · Glitter
Ingredients (not scored): 1% ingredient overlap
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour · Long-wearing rather than 24-hour wear (longevity) · Does not claim comfort · Does not claim hydration
Retailer shade note: asphalt with rainbow sparkles
Matches: Same finish: metallic· Same format: stick· Same longevity: 24-hour wear
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour· Deeper· Buildable rather than opaque (pigmentation)
Score details
Shade match
50
Finish, pigmentation & format
93
Wear & performance
100
Comfort & skin suitability
64
Visibly different colour · Metallic · Buildable
Ingredients (not scored): 23% ingredient overlap
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour · Deeper · Buildable rather than opaque (pigmentation) · Does not claim comfort · Does not claim hydration
Retailer shade note: a shimmering warm taupe / a shimmering blackened green
Matches: Same finish: metallic· Same pigmentation: opaque
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour· Powder rather than stick (format)· Long-wearing rather than 24-hour wear (longevity)
Score details
Shade match
59
Finish, pigmentation & format
90
Wear & performance
55
Comfort & skin suitability
40
Visibly different colour · Metallic · Opaque
Ingredients (not scored): 11% ingredient overlap
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour · Powder rather than stick (format) · Long-wearing rather than 24-hour wear (longevity) · Does not claim crease resistance · Does not claim waterproof · Does not claim comfort · Does not claim hydration
Matches: Same pigmentation: opaque· Same format: stick· Both claim waterproof
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour· Deeper· Black rather than grey
Score details
Shade match
57
Finish, pigmentation & format
89
Wear & performance
50
Comfort & skin suitability
51
Slight colour difference · Glitter · Opaque
Ingredients (not scored): 30% ingredient overlap
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour · Deeper · Black rather than grey · 12-hour wear rather than 24-hour wear (longevity) · Does not claim crease resistance · Does not claim comfort · Does not claim hydration · Normal, Combination rather than normal, dry, combination (skin types)
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour· Lighter· Sheer rather than opaque (pigmentation)
Score details
Shade match
66
Finish, pigmentation & format
74
Wear & performance
40
Comfort & skin suitability
40
Slight colour difference · Shimmer · Sheer
Ingredients (not scored): 21% ingredient overlap
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour · Lighter · Sheer rather than opaque (pigmentation) · Not listed rather than 24-hour wear (longevity) · Does not claim crease resistance · Does not claim waterproof · Does not claim comfort · Does not claim hydration
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour· Powder rather than stick (format)· Long-wearing rather than 24-hour wear (longevity)
Score details
Shade match
60
Finish, pigmentation & format
76
Wear & performance
73
Comfort & skin suitability
24
Visibly different colour · Shimmer
Ingredients (not scored): 10% ingredient overlap
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour · Powder rather than stick (format) · Long-wearing rather than 24-hour wear (longevity) · Does not claim waterproof · Does not claim comfort · Does not claim hydration · Sensitive rather than normal, dry, combination (skin types)
Matches: Same finish: metallic· Same pigmentation: opaque· Both claim crease resistance
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour· Lighter· Black rather than grey
Score details
Shade match
51
Finish, pigmentation & format
90
Wear & performance
74
Comfort & skin suitability
24
Visibly different colour · Metallic · Opaque
Ingredients (not scored): 20% ingredient overlap
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour · Lighter · Black rather than grey · Powder rather than stick (format) · 14-hour wear rather than 24-hour wear (longevity) · Does not claim comfort · Does not claim hydration · Sensitive rather than normal, dry, combination (skin types)
Matches: Both claim crease resistance· Both claim comfort· Both claim hydration
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour· Lighter· Buildable rather than opaque (pigmentation)
Score details
Shade match
55
Finish, pigmentation & format
75
Wear & performance
56
Comfort & skin suitability
100
Visibly different colour · Shimmer · Buildable
Ingredients (not scored): 17% ingredient overlap
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour · Lighter · Buildable rather than opaque (pigmentation) · Liquid rather than stick (format) · 12-hour wear rather than 24-hour wear (longevity) · Does not claim waterproof
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour· Sheer rather than opaque (pigmentation)· Not listed rather than 24-hour wear (longevity)
Score details
Shade match
64
Finish, pigmentation & format
74
Wear & performance
40
Comfort & skin suitability
40
Visibly different colour · Shimmer · Sheer
Ingredients (not scored): 21% ingredient overlap
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour · Sheer rather than opaque (pigmentation) · Not listed rather than 24-hour wear (longevity) · Does not claim crease resistance · Does not claim waterproof · Does not claim comfort · Does not claim hydration
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour· Powder rather than stick (format)· Long-wearing rather than 24-hour wear (longevity)
Score details
Shade match
57
Finish, pigmentation & format
76
Wear & performance
73
Comfort & skin suitability
24
Visibly different colour · Shimmer
Ingredients (not scored): 10% ingredient overlap
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour · Powder rather than stick (format) · Long-wearing rather than 24-hour wear (longevity) · Does not claim waterproof · Does not claim comfort · Does not claim hydration · Sensitive rather than normal, dry, combination (skin types)
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour· Lighter· Powder rather than stick (format)
Score details
Shade match
57
Finish, pigmentation & format
76
Wear & performance
73
Comfort & skin suitability
24
Visibly different colour · Shimmer
Ingredients (not scored): 10% ingredient overlap
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour · Lighter · Powder rather than stick (format) · Long-wearing rather than 24-hour wear (longevity) · Does not claim waterproof · Does not claim comfort · Does not claim hydration · Sensitive rather than normal, dry, combination (skin types)
Matches: Both claim crease resistance· Both claim waterproof· Both claim comfort
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour· Deeper· Buildable rather than opaque (pigmentation)
Score details
Shade match
50
Finish, pigmentation & format
81
Wear & performance
68
Comfort & skin suitability
80
Visibly different colour · Shimmer · Buildable
Ingredients (not scored): 12% ingredient overlap
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour · Deeper · Buildable rather than opaque (pigmentation) · 12-hour wear rather than 24-hour wear (longevity) · Does not claim hydration
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour· Lighter· Powder rather than stick (format)
Score details
Shade match
57
Finish, pigmentation & format
81
Wear & performance
38
Comfort & skin suitability
40
Visibly different colour · Shimmer · Opaque
Ingredients (not scored): 7% ingredient overlap
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour · Lighter · Powder rather than stick (format) · 12-hour wear rather than 24-hour wear (longevity) · Does not claim crease resistance · Does not claim waterproof · Does not claim comfort · Does not claim hydration
Matches: Same finish: metallic· Same format: stick· Both claim waterproof
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour· Lighter· 11-hour wear rather than 24-hour wear (longevity)
Score details
Shade match
44
Finish, pigmentation & format
100
Wear & performance
48
Comfort & skin suitability
40
Visibly different colour · Metallic
Ingredients (not scored): 10% ingredient overlap
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour · Lighter · 11-hour wear rather than 24-hour wear (longevity) · Does not claim crease resistance · Does not claim comfort · Does not claim hydration
Matches: Same pigmentation: opaque· Same format: stick· Both claim waterproof
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour· Lighter· 12-hour wear rather than 24-hour wear (longevity)
Score details
Shade match
48
Finish, pigmentation & format
89
Wear & performance
50
Comfort & skin suitability
51
Visibly different colour · Glitter · Opaque
Ingredients (not scored): 30% ingredient overlap
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour · Lighter · 12-hour wear rather than 24-hour wear (longevity) · Does not claim crease resistance · Does not claim comfort · Does not claim hydration · Normal, Combination rather than normal, dry, combination (skin types)
Retailer shade note: metallic gunmetal grey with sparkling reflects
Matches: Same finish: metallic· Same longevity: 24-hour wear· Both claim crease resistance
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour· Deeper· Black rather than grey
Score details
Shade match
35
Finish, pigmentation & format
90
Wear & performance
100
Comfort & skin suitability
73
Visibly different colour · Metallic
Ingredients (not scored): 14% ingredient overlap
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour · Deeper · Black rather than grey · Liquid rather than stick (format) · Normal rather than normal, dry, combination (skin types)
Matches: Same finish: metallic· Same format: stick· Both claim comfort
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour· Deeper· Buildable rather than opaque (pigmentation)
Score details
Shade match
45
Finish, pigmentation & format
93
Wear & performance
30
Comfort & skin suitability
48
Visibly different colour · Metallic · Buildable
Ingredients (not scored): 8% ingredient overlap
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour · Deeper · Buildable rather than opaque (pigmentation) · 8-hour wear rather than 24-hour wear (longevity) · Does not claim crease resistance · Does not claim waterproof · Does not claim hydration · Sensitive rather than normal, dry, combination (skin types)
Matches: Same format: stick· Both claim waterproof
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour· Deeper· 12-hour wear rather than 24-hour wear (longevity)
Score details
Shade match
45
Finish, pigmentation & format
88
Wear & performance
50
Comfort & skin suitability
40
Visibly different colour · Shimmer
Ingredients (not scored): 28% ingredient overlap
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour · Deeper · 12-hour wear rather than 24-hour wear (longevity) · Does not claim crease resistance · Does not claim comfort · Does not claim hydration
$9Ulta Beauty(product price)$25 less (74%)4.2 (2,863)
Shimmer · Buildable
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour· Buildable rather than opaque (pigmentation)· Powder rather than stick (format)
Score details
Shade match
52
Finish, pigmentation & format
74
Wear & performance
40
Comfort & skin suitability
40
Visibly different colour · Shimmer · Buildable
Ingredients (not scored): 9% ingredient overlap
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour · Buildable rather than opaque (pigmentation) · Powder rather than stick (format) · Not listed rather than 24-hour wear (longevity) · Does not claim crease resistance · Does not claim waterproof · Does not claim comfort · Does not claim hydration
$26Ulta Beauty(product price)$8 less (24%)4.7 (163)
Matches: Same finish: metallic· Both claim crease resistance
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour· Deeper· Blue rather than grey
Score details
Shade match
37
Finish, pigmentation & format
97
Wear & performance
52
Comfort & skin suitability
40
Visibly different colour · Metallic
Ingredients (not scored): no ingredient list for one product
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour · Deeper · Blue rather than grey · 10-hour wear rather than 24-hour wear (longevity) · Does not claim waterproof · Does not claim comfort · Does not claim hydration
$13.99Ulta Beauty(product price)$20.01 less (59%)4.4 (1,922)
Matches: Same finish: metallic
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour· Lighter· Taupe rather than grey
Score details
Shade match
36
Finish, pigmentation & format
97
Wear & performance
40
Comfort & skin suitability
40
Visibly different colour · Metallic
Ingredients (not scored): 7% ingredient overlap
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour · Lighter · Taupe rather than grey · Not listed rather than 24-hour wear (longevity) · Does not claim crease resistance · Does not claim waterproof · Does not claim comfort · Does not claim hydration
Matches: Same finish: metallic· Same format: stick· Same longevity: 24-hour wear
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour· Deeper· Blue rather than grey
Score details
Shade match
25
Finish, pigmentation & format
93
Wear & performance
100
Comfort & skin suitability
64
Visibly different colour · Metallic · Buildable
Ingredients (not scored): 23% ingredient overlap
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour · Deeper · Blue rather than grey · Buildable rather than opaque (pigmentation) · Does not claim comfort · Does not claim hydration
Retailer shade note: a shimmering neutral beige / a rich navy blue
Matches: Same pigmentation: opaque· Both claim waterproof
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour· Deeper· Black rather than grey
Score details
Shade match
64
Finish, pigmentation & format
36
Wear & performance
67
Comfort & skin suitability
37
Slight colour difference · Matte · Opaque
Ingredients (not scored): 10% ingredient overlap
Differences: Noticeably different swatch colour · Deeper · Black rather than grey · Matte rather than metallic (finish) · Long-wearing rather than 24-hour wear (longevity) · Does not claim crease resistance · Does not claim comfort · Does not claim hydration · Dry rather than normal, dry, combination (skin types)
L'Oréal Paris Le Shadow Stick in Moonlit Metal, against Laura Mercier Caviar Stick Eyeshadow in Celestial Noir. Every attribute compared, with its share of the score.
ComparedYour shadeCelestial NoirClosest matchMoonlit MetalHow they compareScore
Shade match55% of overall85
Colour60%76#5e626a#626062Close colourColour difference 4.1 (0 is identical)
Depth15%99Deep / darkDeep / darkSameDepth difference 0.7 on the 0–100 scale
Undertone—not comparableNot listedNot listedUndertone unknown on one side
Colour family25%100GreyGreySameSame colour family
Finish, pigmentation & format30% of overall · 2 of 3 compared97
Pigmentation20%—not comparableOpaqueNot listedNot listed for eitherAn opacity not listed for one product
Format15%85StickCreamCloseCream rather than stick
Wear & performance10% of overall40
Longevity50%4024-hour wearNot listedSome differenceOnly your product claims long wear; the match does not list it
Crease resistance30%40ClaimedNot listedSome differenceOnly your product claims crease resistance; the match does not list it
Waterproof20%40ClaimedNot listedSome differenceOnly your product claims waterproof wear; the match does not list it
Comfort & skin suitability5% of overall · 2 of 3 compared40
Comfort40%40ClaimedNot listedSome differenceOnly your product claims a comfortable feel; the match does not list it
Hydration20%40ClaimedNot listedSome differenceOnly your product claims hydration; the match does not list it
Skin types40%—not comparableNormal, Dry, CombinationNot listedNot listed for eitherSkin types not listed for one product
Overall match 82/100Shade match 85/100Medium confidence· Digital match
Weights are each part's share of the overall match and each attribute's share of its part; an attribute neither product lists is not comparable and its weight goes to the others in its part. Confidence reflects data quality, not similarity. Price and ingredients are not part of either score.
30 similar shades scored two ways: the shade match on colour, depth, undertone and colour family; the overall match on shade match, finish, pigmentation and format, wear and performance and comfort and suitability. A pair with no swatch colour on one side or Low data confidence is listed without a score. Ingredients are shown for information and used by the filters only. Prices are shown next to every match and never change a score. How scoring and confidence work.
Shade colours are sampled from Beautler’s processing of retailer swatch images and are a digital approximation. Prices and stock were last checked when the product was imported; the retailer page is the source of truth.
Ulta Beauty$22.01 less (65%)
Sephora
